Ruto disputes his deputy’s claims on security, intelligence operations

President William Ruto Sunday denied claims by his deputy that the National Intelligence Service (NIS) did not provide adequate intelligence prior to the youth-led anti-tax protests last Tuesday.

Ruto spoke at State House during a presidential roundtable, revealing that the State had adequate intelligence.
This is contrary to Deputy President Rigathi Gachagua’s claims NIS failed to provide actionable intelligence on the protests.

Ruto said there were intelligence reports that criminal elements were planning to infiltrate Tuesday’s peaceful protests, which culminated in a dramatic but historic raid on the August House.

“We had information, and that is why we prepared in the manner that we did, If we had not prepared, we would be counting different numbers of those who died,” Ruto said.

“Criminals mobilised heavily; in fact, many peaceful protesters left town by 10 a.m. after realising criminals had joined the protests.”

Ruto also disagreed with his deputy on the issue of extrajudicial killings, saying that claims that they had resumed under his watch were false.

“It is not fair to discuss the deputy president here because he is not present to explain the context in which he said those things,” Ruto stated.

When asked whether he had spoken with Gachagua about his claims of the return of killings, Ruto asked the interviewers to direct their questions to Gachagua.

“I am sure if you interview the deputy president he will answer that appropriately… but take it from me, extra-judicial killings will not be part of an administration that I’m part of,” he added.

There are reports of a serious fallout between Ruto and Gachagua. A section of church leaders are currently struggling to mend the fences between the two.

Last week, shortly after holding a press briefing in which he said his administration was dropping the widely-rejected Finance Bill, 2024, his deputy called a media briefing, accusing Kenya’s spy agency of failing to give sufficient briefs.

According to Gachagua, if Noordin Haji, the NIS Director General, had not properly informed Ruto of the widespread public opposition to the Bill, Ruto would not have forwarded it to Parliament, avoiding the nationwide protests that erupted on Tuesday, culminating in protesters storming Parliament. Some attacked the Supreme Court, City Hall, several offices and public property across the country in the chaos.

“People had to die, property was destroyed, and protests were held to let the President know how Kenyans felt, but there is an organisation funded by Kenyans to inform the president and the public about Kenyan sentiments.”
“Officers from the National Police Service (NPS) have told me in confidence that they did not receive advance intelligence briefs about the magnitude of the protests. Never have protesters invaded Parliament,” Gachagua claimed.

Gachagua attacked Haji, claiming that he was unfit and lacked the qualifications for the top position in the NIS.
“When he (Haji) was appointed to the office of the Director General, he chased away all the people who were senior to him when he was in the service because of an inferiority complex, crippling NIS and making it dysfunctional,” he said.

“Three directors were chased away and reassigned to desk jobs across the government. 13 assistant directors, men and women with proven track records of intelligence and analysis, were removed from the NIS leaving a shell under a clueless Director General with no capacity to run the organisation. That is why the security sector was caught off guard by the intensity of the protests. Had Noordin Haji done his job; we would not be where we are today.”

Insiders say the attack on Haji stem from the past when he was the Director of Public Prosecutions and had allowed Gachagua’s prosecution over graft.