Oil Market Remains Calm Amid Middle East Turmoil

Despite escalating tensions in the Middle East, the oil market is showing a surprisingly calm response.

Oil prices have risen slightly, but not enough to signal panic, as the world braces for potential conflict in a region critical to global energy supplies.

While oil prices climbed about 2.4% on Tuesday following missile strikes from Iran on Israel, they have remained stable, hovering around $70 a barrel.

This muted reaction highlights a growing sense of complacency among investors, who have become desensitized to previous geopolitical crises that failed to disrupt oil supply significantly.

Bob McNally, president of Rapidan Energy Partners, warned that the situation could worsen, likening it to the story of “the boy who cried wolf.”

He emphasized that the current calm in the oil market does not reflect the real risks associated with a wider conflict. “It’s hard to overstate how complacent the oil markets have become,” he said.

As gas prices have been falling—currently averaging less than $3 per gallon in 18 states—a more significant conflict in the Middle East could quickly change that. McNally noted that this region is crucial for oil production and export, serving as a vital artery for the global economy.

Market Response

Analysts noted that the market’s response would have been much more dramatic in the past. Before the U.S. shale revolution, situations like the current crisis would have sent oil prices soaring above $100 a barrel. In contrast, just two years ago, oil prices spiked to $130 a barrel following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, although that conflict did not lead to the anticipated major supply disruptions.

Now, the key question is how Israel will respond to Iran’s actions and whether this response will impact oil flows from the region. President Biden has indicated that he does not support an Israeli attack on Iranian nuclear facilities, but experts warn that an escalation could jeopardize energy supplies.

Kevin Book, managing director at ClearView Energy Partners, believes the oil market is underestimating the risks. He noted that if Israel were to strike Iranian energy facilities, oil prices could rise from around $74 to $86 a barrel.

Potential Supply Disruptions

The potential impact of such actions could be severe, especially if Iran’s main oil export facility at Kharg Island were attacked. This facility is crucial, accounting for 90% of Iran’s oil exports, which reached 1.8 million barrels per day in August.

A significant loss of oil from Iran could strain global energy prices, and any disruption in the Strait of Hormuz—a critical chokepoint for oil transport—could push prices above $100 a barrel.

Analysts from Citigroup warned that any closure of the Strait would significantly impact global oil markets and the world economy.

While there are contingency plans, such as tapping into the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve, analysts emphasize that any major disruption could lead to immediate price spikes, affecting consumer perceptions of economic stability ahead of the U.S. elections.