Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    KahawatunguKahawatungu
    Button
    • NEWS
    • BUSINESS
    • KNOW YOUR CELEBRITY
    • POLITICS
    • TECHNOLOGY
    • SPORTS
    • HOW-TO
    • WORLD NEWS
    KahawatunguKahawatungu
    COURT NEWS

    Court rejects bid to disqualify bench in petition challenging Kindiki’s rise to Deputy President

    Oki Bin OkiBy Oki Bin OkiDecember 4, 2025Updated:December 4, 2025No Comments4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Telegram Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Telegram Pinterest Email Copy Link

    A three-judge bench dismissed an application seeking their recusal from hearing a petition challenging the constitutionality of Deputy President Kithure Kindiki’s appointment.

    The bench comprising Principal Judge Eric Ogola, Justice Antony Mrima and Justice Florence Mugambi held that petitioner Joseph Enock Aura had failed to prove any reasonable apprehension of bias and therefore lacked grounds to demand their withdrawal from the matter.

    “Accordingly, we find that the applicant has failed to establish a reasonable apprehension of bias on the part of this Bench. The application dated 1st October, 2025 is therefore dismissed,” ruled the court.

    Aura had filed a Notice of Motion dated October 1, 2025, accusing the bench of discriminating against him by allowing his petition, Petition E586 of 2024, to proceed separately instead of being heard as part of the wider consolidated petitions challenging last year’s transition in the Office of the Deputy President.

    But the court faulted Aura for what it termed “ demonstration of bad faith and lack of candour”, saying that it was the petitioner himself through counsel Harrison Kinyanjui who had requested that his case be deconsolidated earlier this year.

    “The segregation of the petition was not a unilateral act of the Court but a direct consequence of the applicant’s own request,” the judges ruled.

    Petition E586 of 2024 is one of several cases filed after the impeachment of former Deputy President Rigathi Gachagua and the appointment and swearing-in of Prof. Kithure Kindiki as his replacement.

    The petitioner, Aura, is seeking to invalidate Kindiki’s appointment, arguing that the entire transition violated the Constitution and several mandatory procedures.

    According to the petition, Aura contends that Kindiki did not formally vacate office as Cabinet Secretary for Interior before he was nominated Deputy President, in violation of constitutional requirements prohibiting the simultaneous holding of two state offices.

    He argues that there was no gazette notice announcing Kindiki’s resignation, nor any formal transition process before nomination and vetting.

    The petition claims that the nomination, approval and swearing-in of Kindiki were conducted in a manner that lacked transparency, breached public participation requirements, and ignored constitutional safeguards meant to regulate transitions into high office.

    Aura further states that the swearing-in ceremony held on November 1 2024 was done without properly declaring a public holiday, rendering it unconstitutional.

    The petition therefore seeks declarations that Kindiki’s appointment, parliamentary vetting, and subsequent swearing-in are null, void and invalid, and that the office should revert to its previous holder pending lawful procedure.

    In his recusal application, Aura claimed that the bench had “irrationally isolated” his petition from the others, allegedly placing him at risk of being unfairly subjected to technical objections such as res judicata.

    But the judges rejected this argument saying Aura’s petition was initially consolidated with the others on January 23, 2025, on the bench’s own directions.

    On May 29, 2025, it was Aura himself who sought deconsolidation to allow the case to proceed separately because he argued it raised “unique issues” requiring a larger bench.

    The Court granted that request for the applicant’s own benefit, not out of bias or discrimination.

    The court said the test for recusal is objective, It must be based on what a reasonable, fully informed observer would conclude, and not on a litigant’s personal dissatisfaction, fears or perceptions.

    They said that recusal cannot be used to “judge-shop” or pressure courts into reorganizing benches to suit litigants’ preferences.

    “The circumstances under which a judge or
    judicial officer should recuse themselves from a case require a high threshold. These instances must be approached objectively, with careful consideration, rather than in a simplistic or routine manner,” said the court.

    “Recusal directly impacts the administration of justice and a judge should not withdraw from a case simply for convenience sake.”

    Stay connected via Google News
    Follow us for the latest news updates and guides.
    Add as preferred source on Google

    Email your news TIPS to Editor@Kahawatungu.com — this is our only official communication channel

    Follow on Facebook Follow on X (Twitter)
    Share. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp LinkedIn Telegram Email
    Oki Bin Oki

    Oki Bin Oki is a seasoned journalist and senior correspondent at Kahawatungu with over a decade of experience reporting on security, crime, politics, world news, and technology. Known for in-depth investigative reporting and sharp analytical coverage, Oki has established a strong track record of delivering accurate, timely, and impactful news to readers across Kenya and beyond.

    Related Posts

    Judges threaten boycott of State of Judiciary Report launch over publication of individual performance data

    November 20, 2026

    AG appeals court ruling on composition of Ruto Cabinet

    November 20, 2026

    Mbadi, Attorney General Oduor found in contempt of court over Kenya’s secret debt agreements

    November 19, 2026

    Comments are closed.

    Latest Posts

    How to Wash an Electric Kettle

    November 21, 2026

    How to Wash an Engine Bay

    November 21, 2026

    How to Wash an Alpaca Blanket

    November 21, 2026

    How to Wash an Apple Watch Band

    November 21, 2026

    Robert Reed Net Worth

    November 21, 2026

    Removal of hat inside Fiona the hippo was ‘impossible’, Cincinnati Zoo says

    November 21, 2026

    French police officers sentenced for beating of music producer Michel Zecler

    November 21, 2026

    Tech stock sell-off drags markets down as Anthropic shares slide

    November 21, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    © 2026 Kahawatungu.com. Designed by Okii.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.